Seleccionar página

Saying private liberties by way of a great constitutional court: The latest exemplory case of gays when you look at the Costa Rica

Bruce Meters. Wilson, Claiming individual liberties owing to a beneficial constitutional court: Brand new instance of gays into the Costa Rica, Around the globe Diary out of Constitutional Rules, Volume 5, Issue dos, , Pages 242–257,


Inside 1989, a freshly written Constitutional Courtroom (Sala IV) quickly turned a very effective courtroom, finish over 160 years of Costa Rican judicial inactivity. The fresh new magistrates’ steps breathed new life on the Composition, ended judicial deference so you’re able to opted officials, and consequently turned Costa Rican governmental life. Concurrently, the new Sala IV magistrates presumed brand new role of guardians away from constitutional liberties, giving rise as to what is normally referred to as a rights trend. The article falls out light on sudden benefits of the forty-year-dated Constitutional file courtesy a study of the latest institutional guidelines and you will strategies not as much as that the new Courtroom works, and it explores the latest achievements and you may failures of just one of the nation’s most marginalized groups in the trying to cover of their constitutional legal rights from the Courtroom.


During the 1999, Costa Ricans notable the Constitution’s fiftieth anniversary. step one New advantages of one’s Composition in these 50 ages is actually frequently split into two distinct attacks, both before and after the brand new 1989 production of a good constitutional chamber off the fresh Finest Legal (Sala Constitucional otherwise Sala IV). 2 In advance of 1989, the constitutionality from lawmakers’ procedures was rarely challenged, and politicians noticed the “capacity to legislate are sheer,” letting them regularly disregard constitutional restrictions to their powers. step three not, the new comprehensive individual and you can societal legal rights specifications of the Constitution was in fact rarely treated because of the Best Legal. 4 What away from Sala IV magistrates possess breathed new life to the Structure and you will turned Costa Rican politics, 5 due to the fact Sala IV possess routinely read and positively decided personal rights claims. It’s generally conformed one, since 1989, Costa Rica has had an official revolution- far more particularly, a “rights” revolution-who’s advised individuals and you can organizations away from nearly all market regarding people to make to your Judge having redress. six

Since magistrates of Supreme Courtroom before deferred for the common twigs regarding regulators, they today act as active guardians of the Composition. In general Sala IV magistrate, Eduardo Sancho, place it: “It’s important to know the latest Sala IV far less an enthusiastic business intended to be at service of the administrator department, however, quite the opposite: to safeguard new liberties men and women.” seven The fresh new magistrates has continuously and decisively ruled inside cases of individual legal rights states, seem to in support of politically weakened and socially ines Sala IV conclusion for the instances submitted of the a few of the most weakly organized, politically and you may socially marginalized members of Costa Rican society. Just before doing so, they covers the fresh new judicial organization construction pre and post the newest production out of Sala IV to spell it out this new roots of your Court’s heightened official activism and you will, specifically, the fresh new restored advantages assumed from the constitutional specifications due to the fact the fresh new chamber was at operation.

step 1. Out-of official inactivity to judicial activism

Into the basic 160 years of versatility, Costa Rica’s Supreme Legal behaved like other other Latin american courts, running on the belief that the methods of one’s well-known twigs from regulators was indeed constitutional unless these people were egregiously and you will definitely if you don’t. 8 As with remaining part, Costa Rica’s constitutions included costs out of rights which were mainly forgotten and you will, more often, merely “parchment traps, useless against political stamina.” nine For decades there’s considerable dispute among the many branches off regulators concerning the judicial feedback. It was not up to 1938 the Ultimate Courtroom depending their “official supremacy from inside the constitutional issues.” ten However,, as in much of with the rest of Latin The usa, the constitutional promises out-of personal rights provided absolutely nothing defense contrary to the caprices out-of political professionals, specifically for marginalized some one. eleven